Question 1
AdvancedAuditing and Attestation (AUD) · Area IV – Forming Conclusions and Reporting
A CPA firm is auditing Innovatech, a pre-IPO software-as-a-service (SaaS) startup. The audit team notes the following:
- Innovatech recognizes revenue from 3-year, non-cancellable contracts at the point of sale, arguing the cash is received upfront and the service is 'always-on'.
- The company recently pivoted its business model, causing significant recurring losses. Management's going concern assessment relies heavily on securing a future Series C funding round, for which they only have a verbal expression of interest from a venture capital firm.
- The lead developer, who wrote most of the proprietary source code, left the company acrimoniously and has threatened litigation over intellectual property rights.
Management refuses to correct the revenue recognition. The auditor concludes that the resulting misstatement is both material and pervasive, and that management's going concern disclosures are inadequate. Which of the following audit opinions is most appropriate?
Answer and explanation
Correct answer: D
Recognizing revenue from 3-year, non-cancellable service contracts at the point of sale departs from ASC 606, under which a stand-ready SaaS obligation is satisfied over time as the service is provided. Management will not correct it, and the auditor has concluded that the misstatement is both material and pervasive (it affects revenue, deferred revenue, net income and equity), so AU-C 705.09 requires an adverse opinion. Inadequate going concern disclosure is also a misstatement that calls for a qualified or adverse opinion (AU-C 570.26). An unmodified opinion with an emphasis-of-matter paragraph is not possible when material misstatements remain uncorrected. A qualified opinion is only for misstatements that are material but not pervasive. A disclaimer of opinion is for an inability to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence (AU-C 705.10), not for uncertainties such as litigation or going concern.
