Question 1
AdvancedMeasure Phase · Measurement System Analysis (MSA)
A pharmaceutical company is validating a new titration process. A Gage R&R study was performed on the measurement system used to determine chemical concentration. The results show a %Contribution from Part-to-Part variation of 65%, Repeatability of 30%, and Reproducibility of 5%. The Number of Distinct Categories is 1. What is the most appropriate next step for the quality team?
Answer and explanation
Correct answer: D
Total Gage R&R is 35% of the observed variance (Repeatability 30% + Reproducibility 5%). Under the AIAG guidelines that Minitab quotes, a Gage R&R %Contribution above 9% is not acceptable, and the number of distinct categories (ndc) should be 5 or more. Minitab computes ndc as 1.41 x (part standard deviation / gage standard deviation), truncated: 1.41 x √(65/35) ≈ 1.9, so ndc = 1 and the system cannot reliably separate one part from another. Almost all of the measurement error is repeatability, the equipment variation seen when the same appraiser measures the same part again, so the device itself (maintenance, calibration, resolution, fixturing) is the first thing to investigate. Retraining operators targets reproducibility, which is only 5%. Part-to-part variation is 65% of the total, so the sample parts are not too similar, and the system is not ready for capability studies.
